Constructive Eviction Information
Constructive eviction occurs when: the landlord's actions or omissions substantially interfere with the tenant's use and enjoyment of the premises (the interference must be substantial, not minor), the landlord fails to remedy the condition after notice, and the tenant vacates the premises within a reasonable time. Common constructive eviction scenarios include: failure to provide essential services (heat, water, or electricity), failure to maintain the premises (severe mold, pest infestation, or structural defects), interference by the landlord (excessive noise from landlord's construction, blocking access, or refusing to provide keys), and failure to address dangerous conditions (health hazards, criminal activity in common areas, or fire safety violations). The tenant must actually vacate: a tenant who remains in possession cannot claim constructive eviction (the tenant must vote with their feet and leave).
Florida Legal Definition
Constructive eviction in Florida is recognized under common law and is related to the statutory obligations under §83.51 (landlord's maintenance obligations). Under Florida case law, constructive eviction requires: a substantial interference with the tenant's use and enjoyment (not merely a minor inconvenience), the interference was caused by the landlord's acts or omissions, the tenant gave the landlord notice and a reasonable opportunity to cure, and the tenant vacated the premises within a reasonable time after the landlord failed to cure. Under §83.56 (residential), the tenant may terminate the lease if the landlord fails to maintain the premises under §83.51 (which codifies some constructive eviction principles). For commercial leases, constructive eviction remains a common law doctrine (Florida has no commercial landlord-tenant statute equivalent to the residential statute).
How It's Used in Practice
In practice, attorneys advise tenants on constructive eviction claims and defend landlords against them. For tenants, the attorney: documents the conditions creating the constructive eviction (photographs, videos, inspection reports, and written correspondence with the landlord), provides written notice to the landlord (specifying the conditions and requesting a cure within a reasonable time), monitors the landlord's response (did the landlord cure within the reasonable time?), advises on the decision to vacate (the tenant must actually vacate to claim constructive eviction; remaining in possession waives the claim), and pursues damages (unpaid rent credits, moving costs, and the difference between the lease rent and the cost of substitute premises). For landlords, the attorney: challenges the substantiality of the interference (arguing the conditions do not rise to the level of constructive eviction), demonstrates the landlord's efforts to cure, argues the tenant did not provide adequate notice, and pursues the tenant for remaining lease obligations if the tenant's constructive eviction claim fails.
Key Takeaways
- Constructive eviction: landlord's breach renders premises substantially unsuitable.
- Tenant must vacate to claim constructive eviction.
- Requirements: substantial interference, notice, failure to cure, and vacation.
- Residential: related to §83.51 landlord maintenance obligations.
- Commercial: common law doctrine; no specific FL statute.
Disclaimer: The information and opinions provided are for general educational, informational or entertainment purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice or a substitute for consultation with a qualified attorney. Any information that you read does not create an attorney–client relationship with Barnes Walker, Goethe, Perron, Shea & Johnson, PLLC, or any of its attorneys. Because laws, regulations, and court interpretations may change over time, the definitions and explanations provided here may not reflect the most current legal standards. The application of law varies depending on your particular facts and jurisdiction. For advice regarding your specific situation, please contact one of our Florida attorneys for personalized guidance.
Business Attorneys
Real Estate Attorneys
Litigation Attorneys
Estate Planning Attorneys
Business Sale Closings
How to Sell a Business in Florida
Contact Information:
Tel: 941-867-7818
Email: info@barneswalker.com
Trust • Experience • Results